F62PART 2CIVIL LEGAL SERVICES AND CRIMINAL DEFENCE SERVICES

Annotations:

Functions of the Department: general

F63Exercise of functions of the Department under this Part3

The Department shall exercise its functions under this Part for the purpose of—

a

securing (within the resources made available, and priorities set, in accordance with this Part) that individuals have access to civil legal services that effectively meet their needs, and promoting the availability to individuals of such services; and

b

securing that individuals involved in criminal investigations or relevant proceedings have access to such criminal defence services as the interests of justice require.

Membership of the CommissionF394

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Power to replace Commission with two bodiesF405

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

PlanningI36

1

The F41Department shall inform itself about—

a

the need for, and the provision of, civil legal services and criminal defence services, and

b

the quality of the services provided.

2

F42The Department shall plan what can be done towards meeting that need by the performance by F42the Department and the Director of their relevant functions .

3

The F43Department may co-operate with such authorities and other bodies and persons as it considers appropriate in facilitating the planning of what can be done by them to meet that need by the use of any resources available to them.

F443A

In this Article and Article 7 “relevant functions” means—

a

in relation to any time after the coming into operation of Article 21, functions under this Order; and

b

in relation to any time before the coming into operation of Article 21, functions under this Order and under Part 3 of the Legal Aid, Advice and Assistance (Northern Ireland) Order 1981.

F454

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

F455

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Powers of Commission7

1

Subject to the provisions of this Part and Article 41, the F48Department may do anything which it considers—

a

is necessary or appropriate for, or for facilitating, the discharge of its F49relevant functions , or

b

is incidental or conducive to the discharge of F50those functions.

2

In particular, the F51Department shall have power under paragraph (1)

a

to enter into any contract,

b

to make grants (with or without conditions),

c

to make loans,

d

to invest money,

e

to promote or assist in the promotion of publicity relating to F52relevant functions ,

f

to undertake any inquiry or investigation which it may consider appropriate in relation to the discharge of any of F52relevant functions , F53...

F53g

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

3

Paragraphs (1) and (2) do not confer on the F54Department power to borrow money.

F554

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

F555

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

I16

In considering any question as to the remuneration of persons or bodies providing civil legal services or criminal defence services (whether in individual cases, or by reference to the provision of such services in specified numbers of cases), the F56Department or the Director shall have regard, among the matters which are relevant, to—

a

the time and skill which the provision of services of the description to which the question relates requires;

b

the number and general level of competence of persons providing those services;

c

the cost to public funds of the remuneration of persons or bodies providing those services; and

d

the need to secure value for money.

I17

Where the F57Department sets fees which are to be paid to persons or bodies in respect of the provision of services by them, nothing in paragraph (6) requires it to have regard to any fee payable, otherwise than in accordance with this Order, in respect of the provision of such services.

GuidanceF468

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

Northern Ireland law and foreign lawI49

1

The F47Department may not fund—

a

civil legal services, or

b

criminal defence services,

relating to any law other than that of Northern Ireland, unless any such law is relevant for determining any issue relating to the law of Northern Ireland.

2

But the Lord Chancellor may, if it appears to him necessary to do so for the purpose of fulfilling any obligation imposed on the United Kingdom by any international agreement, by order specify that such civil legal services or criminal defence services as are specified in the order, relating to the application of such other law as may be so specified, may be funded by the F47Department .

3

For the purposes of the application of paragraph (2) in the case of an obligation to provide for the transmission to other countries of applications for public funding of legal services under their laws, the reference to civil legal services or criminal defence services relating to the application of other laws includes a reference to advice or assistance for the purposes of making and transmitting such an application.

Criminal defence services

Criminal defence services21

1

The Commission shall establish and maintain a fund from which it shall fund—

a

advice and assistance in accordance with Article 23, and

I20b

representation in accordance with Articles 24 and 30,

and in this Order services which can be so funded are referred to as “criminal defence services”.

I202

The Lord Chancellor shall pay to the Commission such sums as are required to meet the costs of any criminal defence services funded by the Commission.

3

The Lord Chancellor may—

a

determine the manner in which and times at which the sums referred to in paragraph (2) shall be paid to the Commission, and

b

impose conditions on the payment of the sums.

4

In funding criminal defence services the Commission shall aim to obtain the best possible value for money.

5

The Commission shall pay into the fund established under paragraph (1)—

a

sums received from the Lord Chancellor under paragraph (2),

b

sums received by the Commission by virtue of an order by a court under Article 31,

c

sums received by the Commission by virtue of an order by a court under section 4 or 6 of the Costs in Criminal Cases Act (Northern Ireland) 1968F1, and

C1d

such other receipts of the Commission as the Lord Chancellor may, with the concurrence of the Treasury, determine.

6

Where the Commission considers that the amount in the fund established under paragraph (1) significantly exceeds the amount which will be paid out before the next payment by the Lord Chancellor under paragraph (2), it shall—

a

inform the Lord Chancellor, and

b

if he so directs, pay to the Lord Chancellor so much of the excess as is specified in the direction.

Criminal defence services: code of conduct22

1

The Commission shall prepare a code of conduct to be observed by employees of the Commission, and employees of any body established and maintained by the Commission, in the provision of criminal defence services.

2

The code shall include—

a

duties imposed in accordance with any scheme made by the Commission under Schedule 9 to the Northern Ireland Act 1998F2 (equality schemes),

b

duties to protect the interests of the individuals for whom criminal defence services are provided,

c

duties to the court,

d

duties to avoid conflicts of interest, and

e

duties of confidentiality,

and duties on employees who are members of a professional body to comply with the rules of the body.

3

The Commission may from time to time prepare a revised version of the code.

4

Before preparing or revising the code the Commission shall consult the Law Society and the General Council of the Bar of Northern Ireland and such other bodies or persons as it considers appropriate.

5

After preparing the code or a revised version of the code the Commission shall send a copy to the Lord Chancellor.

6

If he approves it he shall lay it before F3the Assembly.

7

The Commission shall publish—

a

the code as first approved by the Lord Chancellor, and

b

where he approves a revised version, either the revisions or the revised code as appropriate.

8

The code, and any revised version of the code, shall not come into force until it has been approved by a resolution of F4the Assembly.

Advice and assistance23

1

The Commission shall fund such advice and assistance as it considers appropriate—

a

for individuals who are arrested and held in custody at a police station or other premises, and

b

in prescribed circumstances, for individuals who—

i

are not within sub-paragraph (a) but are involved in investigations which may lead to relevant proceedings,

I26ii

are before a court or other body in such proceedings, or

I26iii

have been the subject of such proceedings.

2

The Commission may comply with the duty imposed by paragraph (1) by—

a

entering into contracts with persons or bodies for the provision of advice or assistance by them,

b

making payments to persons or bodies in respect of the provision of advice or assistance by them,

c

making grants or loans to persons or bodies to enable them to provide, or facilitate the provision of, advice or assistance,

d

establishing and maintaining bodies to provide, or facilitate the provision of, advice or assistance,

e

making grants to individuals to enable them to obtain advice or assistance,

f

employing persons to provide advice or assistance, or

g

doing anything else which it considers appropriate for funding advice and assistance.

I263

The Lord Chancellor may by order require the Commission to discharge the function in paragraph (2) in accordance with the order.

4

The Commission may fund advice and assistance by different means—

a

in different areas in Northern Ireland, and

b

in relation to different descriptions of cases.

Representation24

I211

The Commission shall fund representation to which an individual has been granted a right in accordance with Articles 25 to 29.

2

Subject to the following provisions, the Commission may comply with the duty imposed by paragraph (1) by—

a

entering into contracts with persons or bodies for the provision of representation by them,

b

making payments to persons or bodies in respect of the provision of representation by them,

c

making grants or loans to persons or bodies to enable them to provide, or facilitate the provision of, representation,

d

establishing and maintaining bodies to provide, or facilitate the provision of, representation,

e

making grants to individuals to enable them to obtain representation,

f

employing persons to provide representation, or

g

doing anything else which it considers appropriate for funding representation.

I213

The Lord Chancellor—

a

shall by order make provision about the payments which may be made by the Commission in respect of any representation provided by non-contracted private practitioners, F61...

F61b

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

I214

For the purposes of paragraph (3)(a) representation is provided by a non-contracted private practitioner if it is provided, otherwise than pursuant to a contract entered into by the Commission, by a person or body which is neither—

a

a person or body in receipt of grants or loans made by the Commission under paragraph (2), nor

b

the Commission itself or a body established or maintained by the Commission.

I215

The provision which the Lord Chancellor is required to make by order under paragraph (3)(a) includes provision for reviews of, or appeals against, determinations for the purposes of the order.

6

The Commission may fund representation by different means—

a

in different areas in Northern Ireland, and

b

in relation to different descriptions of cases.

Individuals to whom right to representation may be granted25

1

A right to representation may be granted—

I22a

for the purposes of any kind of proceedings specified in paragraph (2), to an individual such as is mentioned in that paragraph in relation to that kind of proceedings;

I22b

to an individual for the purposes of enabling him to resist an appeal in proceedings specified in paragraph (2) otherwise than in an official capacity;

c

for the purposes of a diversionary youth conference, to a child with respect to whom the conference has been, or is to be, convened,

d

to an individual for the purposes of proceedings concerning him which are of such a kind, and are before such court or other body, as may be prescribed,

and in this Order proceedings mentioned in paragraphs (a) to (d) are referred to as “relevant proceedings”.

2

The proceedings referred to in paragraph (1)(a) and (b) are—

a

proceedings before any court for dealing with an individual accused of an offence,

b

proceedings before—

I22i

any court, or

ii

the F5Parole Commissioners for Northern Ireland,

for dealing with an individual convicted of an offence (including proceedings in respect of a sentence or order),

F6c

proceedings for dealing with an individual under Part I or II of the Extradition Act 2003 (c.41);

d

proceedings for binding an individual over to keep the peace or to be of good behaviour under Article 127 of the Magistrates' Courts (Northern Ireland) Order 1981, and for dealing with an individual who fails to comply with an order under that Article,

I22e

proceedings on an appeal brought by an individual under section 47A of the Criminal Appeal (Northern Ireland) Act 1980F7,

I22f

proceedings for contempt committed, or alleged to have been committed, by an individual in the face of a court, and

g

proceedings for dealing with an individual in respect of whom an application has been made under—

i

Article 44 or 45 of the Police and Criminal Evidence (Northern Ireland) Order 1989F8, or

ii

paragraph 29 or 36 of Schedule 8 to the Terrorism Act 2000F9,

but do not include any proceedings for a writ of habeas corpus or other prerogative remedy.

F6h

proceedings under Part XIIIA of the Prison and Young Offenders Centre Rules (Northern Ireland) 1995 (No. 8).

Grant of right to representation by court26

I231

A court before which any relevant proceedings take place, or are to take place, has power to grant a right to representation in respect of those proceedings except in such circumstances as may be prescribed.

I272

Where a right to representation is granted for the purposes of relevant proceedings then, subject to paragraph (5)—

a

it includes the right to representation for the purposes of any related bail proceedings, any related court-ordered youth conference, and any preliminary or incidental proceedings; and regulations may make provision specifying whether any proceedings are or are not to be regarded as preliminary or incidental; and

b

it includes the right to such advice and assistance, as to any appeal, as may be prescribed.

I273

A court also has power to grant a right to representation for the purposes of relevant proceedings before another court in such circumstances as may be prescribed.

4

A magistrates' court also has power to grant a right to representation for the purposes of a diversionary youth conference.

I275

A court has power to grant representation for a limited period, for the purposes of specified proceedings only or for the purposes of limited aspects of proceedings, and to vary or remove any limitation imposed on representation.

6

Regulations may make provision—

a

as to the form of any application for a grant of a right to representation under this Article;

b

as to the information which must be supplied with any such application;

c

as to the form of any grant of a right to representation under this Article;

d

requiring the court granting a right to representation under this Article to indicate the grounds on which the right was granted.

7

Before making any regulations under paragraph (6) the Lord Chancellor shall consult the Lord Chief Justice.

I238

The refusal of a right to representation before a hearing shall not prevent the applicant being granted a right to representation at the hearing.

9

A right to representation in respect of proceedings may be withdrawn—

a

by any court before which the proceedings take place, or

b

in the case of a diversionary youth conference, by a magistrates' court;

and a court must consider whether to withdraw a right to representation in such circumstances as may be prescribed.

10

In this Article “court” includes any body before which relevant proceedings take place.

Grant of right to representation by Commission27

1

Regulations may provide that the Commission shall have power to grant rights to representation in respect of any one or more of the descriptions of proceedings prescribed under Article 25(1)(d), and to withdraw any rights to representation granted by it.

2

Regulations under paragraph (1) may provide that the Commission shall have power to grant representation for a limited period or for the purposes of specified proceedings only or for the purposes of limited aspects of proceedings, and to vary or remove any limitation imposed on representation.

3

Regulations under paragraph (1) may make provision—

a

as to the form of any application for a grant of a right to representation under those regulations;

b

as to the information which must be supplied with any such application;

c

as to the form of any grant of a right to representation under those regulations;

d

requiring the Commission to indicate the grounds on which any right to representation is granted under those regulations.

Appeals28

Except where regulations otherwise provide, an appeal shall lie to such court or other person or body as may be prescribed against a decision—

a

to refuse a right to representation in respect of relevant proceedings;

b

to impose or vary a limitation on such a right;

c

not to extend such a right; or

d

to withdraw such a right.

Criteria for grant of right to representationI2429

1

Any question as to whether a right to representation should be granted or extended, or whether a limitation on representation should be imposed, varied or removed, shall be determined according to the interests of justice.

2

In deciding what the interests of justice consist of in relation to any individual, the following factors must be taken into account—

a

whether the individual would, if any matter arising in the proceedings is decided against him, be likely to lose his liberty or livelihood or suffer serious damage to his reputation,

b

whether the determination of any matter arising in the proceedings may involve consideration of a substantial question of law,

c

whether the individual may be unable to understand the proceedings or to state his own case,

d

whether the proceedings may involve the tracing, interviewing or expert cross-examination of witnesses on behalf of the individual, and

e

whether it is in the interests of another person that the individual be represented.

3

The Lord Chancellor may by order amend paragraph (2) by adding new factors or varying any factor.

4

A right to representation shall always be granted in such circumstances as may be prescribed.

Selection of representative30

I251

An individual who has been granted a right to representation in accordance with Articles 25 to 29 may, subject to Article 35, select any representative or representatives willing to act for him; and, where he does so, the Commission is to comply with the duty imposed by Article 24 by funding representation by the selected representative or representatives.

2

Regulations may provide that in prescribed circumstances—

a

the right conferred by paragraph (1) is not to apply in cases of prescribed descriptions,

b

an individual who has been provided with advice or assistance funded by the Commission under Article 23 by a person whom he chose to provide it for him is to be taken to have selected that person as his representative pursuant to that right,

c

that right is not to include a right to select a representative of a prescribed description,

d

that right is to select only a registered person within the meaning of Article 36, or only a representative of a prescribed description,

e

that right is to select not more than a prescribed number of representatives to act at any one time,

f

that right is not to include a right to select a representative in place of a representative previously selected.

3

Regulations under paragraph (2)(b) may prescribe circumstances in which an individual is to be taken to have chosen a person to provide advice or assistance for him.

4

Regulations under paragraph (2) may not provide that only a person employed by the Commission, or by a body established and maintained by the Commission, may be selected.

5

Regulations may provide that in prescribed circumstances the Commission is not required to fund, or to continue to fund, representation for an individual by a particular representative (but such provision shall not prejudice any right of the individual to select another representative).

6

The circumstances which may be prescribed by regulations under paragraph (2) or (5) include that a determination has been made by a prescribed body or person.

7

A representative who has been selected to act for an individual under this paragraph may select another person to act for that individual, as the agent of the representative, if that other person is of such a description that nothing in Article 35 would prohibit the individual selecting him as his representative.

Terms of provision of funded services31

1

An individual for whom criminal defence services are funded by the Commission shall not be required to make any payment in respect of the services except where paragraph (2) applies.

2

Where representation for an individual in respect of relevant proceedings in any court is funded by the Commission under Article 24, the court may, subject to regulations under paragraph (3), make an order requiring him to pay some or all of the cost of any representation so funded for him (in proceedings in that or any other court, or in any related court-ordered youth conference).

3

Regulations may make provision about—

a

the descriptions of courts by which, and individuals against whom, an order under paragraph (2) may be made,

b

the circumstances in which such an order may be made and the principles to be applied in deciding whether to make such an order and the amount to be paid,

c

the determination of the cost of representation for the purposes of the making of such an order,

d

the furnishing of information and evidence to the court or the Commission for the purpose of enabling the court to decide whether to make such an order and (if so) the amount to be paid,

e

prohibiting individuals who are required to furnish information or evidence from dealing with property until they have furnished the information or evidence or until a decision whether to make an order, or the amount to be paid, has been made,

f

rights of appeal against such an order,

g

the person or body to which, and manner in which, payments required by such an order must be made and what that person or body is to do with them, and

h

the enforcement of such an order (including provision for the imposition of charges in respect of unpaid amounts).

Supplementary

Restriction of disclosure of informationI1332

1

Information which is furnished—

a

to the F32Department or any court, tribunal or other person or body on whom functions are imposed or conferred by or under this Part, and

b

in connection with the case of an individual seeking or receiving civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F32Department ,

shall not be disclosed except as permitted by regulations.

2

Paragraph (1) does not limit the disclosure of—

a

information in the form of a summary or collection of information so framed as not to enable information relating to any individual to be ascertained from it, or

b

information about the amount of any grant, loan or other payment made to any person or body by the F32Department .

3

Paragraph (1) does not prevent the disclosure of information for any purpose with the consent of the individual in connection with whose case it was furnished and, where he did not furnish it himself, with that of the person or body who did.

4

A person who discloses any information in contravention of this Article shall be guilty of an offence and liable on summary conviction to a fine not exceeding level 4 on the standard scale.

5

Proceedings for an offence under this Article shall not be brought except by or with the consent of the Attorney General.

6

Nothing in this Article applies to information furnished to a person providing civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F32Department by or on behalf of an individual seeking or receiving such services.

Misrepresentation etc.I1433

1

Any person who—

a

intentionally fails to comply with any requirement imposed by virtue of this Part as to the information to be furnished by him, or

b

in furnishing any information required by virtue of this Part makes any statement or representation which he knows or believes to be false,

shall be guilty of an offence.

2

A person guilty of an offence under paragraph (1) is liable on summary conviction to—

a

a fine not exceeding level 4 on the standard scale, or

b

imprisonment for a term not exceeding three months,

or to both.

3

Notwithstanding any statutory provision prescribing the period within which summary proceedings may be commenced, proceedings in respect of an offence under paragraph (1) may be commenced at any time within the period of six months beginning with the date on which evidence, sufficient in the opinion of the Attorney General to justify a prosecution for the offence, comes to his knowledge.

4

But paragraph (3) does not authorise the commencement of proceedings for an offence at a time more than two years after the date on which the offence was committed.

5

For the purposes of paragraph (3) a certificate purporting to be signed by the Attorney General as to the date on which evidence such as is mentioned in that paragraph has come to his knowledge, shall be conclusive evidence thereof.

6

A county court shall, notwithstanding any limitation imposed on the jurisdiction of a county court under any other statutory provision, have jurisdiction to hear and determine any action brought by the F58Department to recover loss sustained by reason of—

a

the failure of any person to comply with any requirement imposed by virtue of this Part as to the information to be furnished by him, or

b

a false statement or false representation made by any person in furnishing any information required by virtue of this Part.

Position of service providers and other parties etc.I1534

1

Except as expressly provided by regulations, the fact that civil legal services or criminal defence services provided for an individual are or could be funded by the F59Department , shall not affect—

a

the relationship between that individual and the person by whom they are provided or any privilege arising out of that relationship, or

b

any right which that individual may have to be indemnified, in respect of expenses incurred by him, by any other person.

2

A person who provides civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F59Department shall not take any payment in respect of the services apart from—

a

that made by way of that funding, and

b

any authorised by the F59Department to be taken.

3

Where civil legal services funded by the F59Department are provided in connection with any proceedings, any expenses incurred in connection with the proceedings, so far as they would ordinarily be paid in the first instance by or on behalf of the person providing the services, shall be so paid except where they are paid by the F59Department .

4

The withdrawal of a right to representation previously granted to an individual shall not affect the right of any person who has provided to him civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F59Department to remuneration for work done before the date of the withdrawal.

5

Except as expressly provided by regulations, any rights conferred by or by virtue of this Part on an individual for whom civil legal services or criminal defence services are funded by the F59Department in relation to any proceedings shall not affect—

a

the rights or liabilities of other parties to the proceedings, or

b

the principles on which the discretion of any court or tribunal is normally exercised.

6

Regulations may make provision about the procedure of any court or tribunal in relation to civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F59Department .

7

Regulations made under paragraph (6) may in particular authorise the exercise of the functions of any court or tribunal by any member or officer of that or any other court or tribunal.

Solicitors and barristersI1635

1

The F60Department shall not fund any civil legal services or criminal defence services provided by a solicitor who is for the time being prohibited from providing such services by an order under Article 51B(1) or (3) of the Solicitors (Northern Ireland) Order 1976F10.

2

The F60Department shall not fund any civil legal services or criminal defence services provided by a barrister who is for the time being prohibited from providing such services by any determination of the General Council of the Bar of Northern Ireland, or by any determination of any such committee as may be established by that Council to determine charges preferred against barristers.

3

The F60Department

a

may make a complaint to the Law Society about the provision of civil legal services or criminal defence services by a solicitor;

b

may refer to the Law Society any complaint which is made to the F60Department about the provision of such services by a solicitor;

c

may make a complaint to the General Council of the Bar of Northern Ireland about the provision of civil legal services or criminal defence services by a barrister; and

d

may refer to the General Council of the Bar of Northern Ireland any complaint which is made to the F60Department about the provision of such services by a barrister.

4

Any right conferred on an individual by virtue of this Part to select a person to provide civil legal services or criminal defence services for him shall not prejudice the law and practice relating to the conduct of proceedings by a solicitor or barrister or the circumstances in which a solicitor or counsel may refuse or give up a case or entrust it to another.

Register of persons providing servicesI1736

1

Regulations may—

a

make provision for the registration by the F33Department of persons who are eligible to provide civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F33Department ;

b

provide that only those persons who are registered ( “registered persons”) may provide such services; and

c

require registration of firms or organisations with which registered persons are connected.

2

Regulations may require the F33Department to prepare a code of practice in relation to—

a

the conditions to be complied with in order to qualify for registration, and

b

the carrying out by registered persons, and any firm or organisation which is registered in connection with a registered person, of their functions with regard to civil legal services or criminal defence services funded by the F33Department .

3

Regulations—

a

may require registered persons, and any firm or organisation which is registered in connection with a registered person, to comply with any such code of practice;

b

F34may require the F33Department or persons authorised by the F33Department to monitor compliance with any such code of practice; and

c

may make provision about procedures for cases in which—

i

it appears to the F33Department or a person authorised by the F33Department that a registered person, or any firm or organisation which is registered in connection with a registered person, may not be complying with any such code of practice, or

ii

a person who holds any judicial office asks the F33Department to investigate whether a registered person, or any firm or organisation which is registered in connection with a registered person, is complying with any such code of practice,

and the sanctions which may be imposed under this sub-paragraph may include provision for a person, firm or organisation to cease to be registered.

4

Regulations under this Article—

a

may make provision imposing charges;

b

may make provision with respect to the powers of investigation which may be exercised by the F33Department , or by persons authorised by the F33Department , for the purpose of monitoring compliance with any code of practice prepared under the regulations;

c

may make provision for obstruction of the exercise of powers conferred by virtue of sub-paragraph (b) to be certified to the High Court in prescribed circumstances, and for any power of the court in relation to contempt of court to be exercisable in relation to such obstruction.

5

Before making any regulations under this Article the Lord Chancellor—

a

shall consult the Lord Chief Justice, the Law Society and the General Council of the Bar of Northern Ireland, and

b

may undertake such other consultation as appears to him to be appropriate.