<Legislation xmlns="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/namespaces/legislation" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447" NumberOfProvisions="9" xsi:schemaLocation="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/namespaces/legislation http://www.legislation.gov.uk/schema/legislation.xsd" SchemaVersion="2.0" RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2023-07-11"><ukm:Metadata xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" xmlns:dct="http://purl.org/dc/terms/" xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom" xmlns:ukm="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/namespaces/metadata">
					<dc:identifier>http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447</dc:identifier><dc:title>Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012 of 21 March 2012 supplementing Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on credit rating agencies by laying down regulatory technical standards for the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies (Text with EEA relevance)</dc:title><dct:alternative>Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012</dct:alternative><dc:description>Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012 of 21 March 2012 supplementing Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on credit rating agencies by laying down regulatory technical standards for the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies (Text with EEA relevance)</dc:description><dc:publisher>King's Printer of Acts of Parliament</dc:publisher><dc:source>https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/eu-exit/https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=CELEX:32012R0447</dc:source><dc:type>text</dc:type><dc:format>text/xml</dc:format><dc:language>en</dc:language><dc:modified>2023-12-08</dc:modified><dc:contributor>Expert Participation</dc:contributor><dct:valid>2023-07-11</dct:valid>
					
					<atom:link rel="self" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.xml" type="application/xml"/><atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/navigation/resources" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/resources" title="More Resources"/>
					
					
					
					<atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/navigation/act" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447" title="whole act"/><atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/navigation/introduction" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/introduction" title="introduction"/><atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/navigation/signature" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/signature" title="signature"/>
					<atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/navigation/body" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/body" title="body"/>
					
					
					<atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/date/euexitday" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/2020-01-31" title="2020-01-31"/><atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/date/euexitTransitionEnd" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/2020-12-31" title="2020-12-31"/>					
					<atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/powerToAmend" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2018/1115" title="XXXX may be subject to amendment by EU Exit Instruments made by the Financial Conduct Authority under powers set out in The Financial Regulators' Powers (Technical Standards etc.) (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2018 (S.I. 2018/1115), regs. 2, 3, Sch. Pt. 1. These amendments are not currently available on legislation.gov.uk. Details of relevant amending instruments can be found on their website/s."/>
					<atom:link rel="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/def/legislation/EffectsApplied" href="https://www.legislation.gov.uk/changes/applied/affected/eur/2012/447" title="Amended by UK"/>
					
					<atom:link rel="alternate" type="application/rdf+xml" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.rdf" title="RDF/XML"/><atom:link rel="alternate" type="application/akn+xml" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.akn" title="AKN"/><atom:link rel="alternate" type="application/xhtml+xml" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.xht" title="HTML snippet"/><atom:link rel="alternate" type="text/html" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.htm" title="Website (XHTML) Default View"/><atom:link rel="alternate" type="text/csv" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.csv" title="CSV"/><atom:link rel="alternate" type="application/pdf" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.pdf" title="PDF"/>
					<atom:link rel="alternate" type="application/akn+xhtml" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/data.html" title="HTML5 snippet"/>

					<atom:link rel="alternate" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/pdfs/eur_20120447_adopted_en.pdf" type="application/pdf" title="Original PDF"/>
					<atom:link rel="http://purl.org/dc/terms/tableOfContents" hreflang="en" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/contents" title="Table of Contents"/>
					
					<atom:link rel="http://purl.org/dc/terms/replaces" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/2020-12-31" title="2020-12-31"/><atom:link rel="http://purl.org/dc/terms/hasVersion" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/adopted" title="adopted"/><atom:link rel="http://purl.org/dc/terms/hasVersion" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/2012-03-21" title="2012-03-21"/><atom:link rel="http://purl.org/dc/terms/hasVersion" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/2020-12-31" title="2020-12-31"/><atom:link rel="http://purl.org/dc/terms/hasVersion" href="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/2023-07-11" title="2023-07-11"/>
					
					
					<ukm:EUMetadata><ukm:DocumentClassification>
            <ukm:DocumentCategory Value="euretained"/>
            <ukm:DocumentMainType Value="EuropeanUnionRegulation"/>
            <ukm:DocumentStatus Value="revised"/>
         </ukm:DocumentClassification><ukm:Year Value="2012"/><ukm:Number Value="447"/><ukm:EURLexIdentifiers>
            <ukm:Cellar Value="d24a8a3e-5125-4547-b352-d840929bedbc"/>
            <ukm:OfficialJournal Value="JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01"/>
            <ukm:ELI Value="reg_del:2012:447:oj"/>
            <ukm:CELEX Value="32012R0447"/>
         </ukm:EURLexIdentifiers><ukm:EnactmentDate Date="2012-03-21"/><ukm:EURLexModified Date="2016-08-16T17:28:57Z"/><ukm:EURLexExtracted Date="2018-05-21T21:37:37Z"/><ukm:XMLGenerated Date="2020-12-11T21:13:04Z"/><ukm:XMLImported Date="2020-12-11T22:19:19Z"/><ukm:Treaty Title="Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (consolidated version 2008)" Code="TFEU_2008"/><ukm:CreatedBy Label="European Commission" URI="http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body/COM"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="auditing" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/4675"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="EU office or agency" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5769"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="evaluation method" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/6263"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="SubjectMatter" Label="Internal market - Principles" URI="http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_070/MARI"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="financial analysis" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/1811"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="audit" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/6064"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="DirectoryCode" Label="Other service activities" URI="http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/06202080"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="DirectoryCode" Label="Right of establishment and freedom to provide services" URI="http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/06"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="DirectoryCode" Label="Sectoral application" URI="http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/0620"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="DirectoryCode" Label="Service activities" URI="http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/062020"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="economic forecasting" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/2616"/><ukm:Subject Scheme="EuroVoc" Label="administrative supervision" URI="http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5945"/><ukm:EURLexMetadata>
            <WORK xmlns="">
               <URI>
                  <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/d24a8a3e-5125-4547-b352-d840929bedbc</VALUE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>d24a8a3e-5125-4547-b352-d840929bedbc</IDENTIFIER>
                  <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
               </URI>
               <SAMEAS>
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                  </URI>
               </SAMEAS>
               <SAMEAS>
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/eli/reg_del/2012/447/oj</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>reg_del:2012:447:oj</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>eli</TYPE>
                  </URI>
               </SAMEAS>
               <SAMEAS>
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/celex/32012R0447</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>32012R0447</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>celex</TYPE>
                  </URI>
               </SAMEAS>
               <DATE_DOCUMENT type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-03-21</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>03</MONTH>
                  <DAY>21</DAY>
               </DATE_DOCUMENT>
               <ELI type="data">
                  <VALUE>http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2012/447/oj</VALUE>
               </ELI>
               <CREATED_BY type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body/COM</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>COM</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>corporate-body</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>COM</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>COM</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>European Commission</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Commission of the European Communities</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>European Commission</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Commission</ALTLABEL>
               </CREATED_BY>
               <WORK_PART_OF_COLLECTION_DOCUMENT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/document-collection/JO</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>JO</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>document-collection</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>JO</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>JO</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>JO</PREFLABEL>
               </WORK_PART_OF_COLLECTION_DOCUMENT>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_COMMENT_INTERNAL type="data">
                  <VALUE>MAN2</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_COMMENT_INTERNAL>
               <WORK_ID_DOCUMENT type="data">
                  <VALUE>oj:JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01</VALUE>
               </WORK_ID_DOCUMENT>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_DATE_END-OF-VALIDITY type="date">
                  <VALUE>9999-12-31</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>9999</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>12</MONTH>
                  <DAY>31</DAY>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_DATE_END-OF-VALIDITY>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5945</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>5945</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>5945</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>administrative supervision</PREFLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_INFORMATION_MISCELLANEOUS type="data">
                  <VALUE>{P/EEE|http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_400/P%2FEEE}</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_INFORMATION_MISCELLANEOUS>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/4675</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>4675</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>4675</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>auditing</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/1155</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>1155</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1155</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>management accounting</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100152</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100152</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>40</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>40 BUSINESS AND COMPETITION</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100230</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100230</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>4026</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>4026 accounting</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_HAS_TYPE_ACT_CONCEPT_TYPE_ACT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_030/REGDEL</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>REGDEL</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>fd_030</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>REGDEL</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>REGDEL</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>Delegated regulation</PREFLABEL>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_HAS_TYPE_ACT_CONCEPT_TYPE_ACT>
               <IDENTIFIER type="data">
                  <VALUE>1012970</VALUE>
               </IDENTIFIER>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5769</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>5769</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>5769</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>EU office or agency</PREFLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>specialised Community agency</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European Union office or agency</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EC specialised body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European agency</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European Monitoring Centre</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EC institutional body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>Community service body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EC satellite body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EU Agencies and decentralised bodies</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European foundation</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>decentralised Community body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>autonomous Community body</ALTLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5769</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>5769</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>5769</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>EU office or agency</PREFLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>specialised Community agency</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European Union office or agency</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EC specialised body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European agency</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European Monitoring Centre</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EC institutional body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>Community service body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EC satellite body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>EU Agencies and decentralised bodies</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>European foundation</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>decentralised Community body</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>autonomous Community body</ALTLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100144</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100144</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>10</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>10 EUROPEAN UNION</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100174</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100174</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1006</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>1006 EU institutions and European civil service</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/6263</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>6263</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6263</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>evaluation method</PREFLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>evaluation</ALTLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/2914</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>2914</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>2914</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>research</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100158</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100158</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>64</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>64 PRODUCTION, TECHNOLOGY AND RESEARCH</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100262</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100262</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6416</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>6416 research and intellectual property</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_DATE_ENTRY-INTO-FORCE type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-06-19</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>06</MONTH>
                  <DAY>19</DAY>
                  <ANNOTATION>
                     <BUILD_INFO>cdm:CDM_2.1.7  tdm:1523  xslt:3945 saxon:9.0.0.1J JVM:1.6.0_29 metaconvJar:1.2.0 builddate:11/04/2014 15:17:05</BUILD_INFO>
                     <COMMENT_ON_DATE>{DATPUB|http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_335/DATPUB} +20 {V|http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_335/V} {ART|http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_335/ART} 9</COMMENT_ON_DATE>
                     <TYPE_OF_DATE>{EV|http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_335/EV}</TYPE_OF_DATE>
                  </ANNOTATION>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_DATE_ENTRY-INTO-FORCE>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/2616</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>2616</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>2616</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>economic forecasting</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>economic projection</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>economic prospects</ALTLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_PUBLISHED_IN_OFFICIAL-JOURNAL type="link">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/a20a3963-0dbb-4762-9753-17ef0278c919</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>a20a3963-0dbb-4762-9753-17ef0278c919</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/JOL_2012_140_R</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>JOL_2012_140_R</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_PUBLISHED_IN_OFFICIAL-JOURNAL>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_REPERTOIRE type="data">
                  <VALUE>REP</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_REPERTOIRE>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_SUBJECT-MATTER type="concept_level">
                  <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_SUBJECT-MATTER_1 type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_070/MARI</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>MARI</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>fd_070</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <OP-CODE>MARI</OP-CODE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>MARI</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>Internal market - Principles</PREFLABEL>
                  </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_SUBJECT-MATTER_1>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_SUBJECT-MATTER>
               <BASED_ON type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/treaty/TFEU_2008</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>TFEU_2008</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>treaty</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>TFEU_2008</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>TFEU_2008</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (consolidated version 2008)</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>TFEU (2008)</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Consolidated version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (2008)</ALTLABEL>
               </BASED_ON>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/6064</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6064</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>6064</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>audit</PREFLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <DATE type="date">
                  <VALUE>9999-12-31</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>9999</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>12</MONTH>
                  <DAY>31</DAY>
               </DATE>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/1811</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>1811</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1811</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>financial analysis</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/1164</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>1164</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1164</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>financial management</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100152</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100152</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>40</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>40 BUSINESS AND COMPETITION</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100229</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100229</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>4021</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>4021 management</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <IDENTIFIER type="data">
                  <VALUE>32012R0447</VALUE>
               </IDENTIFIER>
               <ID_SECTOR type="data">
                  <VALUE>3</VALUE>
               </ID_SECTOR>
               <IDENTIFIER type="data">
                  <VALUE>celex:32012R0447</VALUE>
               </IDENTIFIER>
               <DATE type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-05-30</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>05</MONTH>
                  <DAY>30</DAY>
               </DATE>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_BASED_ON_RESOURCE_LEGAL type="link">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/6e35c7f1-c976-4c9f-83d9-f5919e956de0</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6e35c7f1-c976-4c9f-83d9-f5919e956de0</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/eli/reg/2009/1060/oj</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>reg:2009:1060:oj</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>eli</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/JOL_2009_302_R_0001_01</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>JOL_2009_302_R_0001_01</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/celex/32009R1060</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>32009R1060</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>celex</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <ANNOTATION>
                     <BUILD_INFO>cdm:CDM_2.1.7  tdm:1523  xslt:3945 saxon:9.0.0.1J JVM:1.6.0_29 metaconvJar:1.2.0 builddate:11/04/2014 15:17:05</BUILD_INFO>
                     <COMMENT_ON_LEGAL_BASIS>A21P4PTD)</COMMENT_ON_LEGAL_BASIS>
                     <ARTICLE>21</ARTICLE>
                     <PARAGRAPH>4</PARAGRAPH>
                  </ANNOTATION>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_BASED_ON_RESOURCE_LEGAL>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_NUMBER_NATURAL_CELEX type="data">
                  <VALUE>0447</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_NUMBER_NATURAL_CELEX>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/1811</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1811</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>1811</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>financial analysis</PREFLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/6064</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>6064</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6064</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>audit</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/1154</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>1154</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1154</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>management</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100152</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100152</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>40</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>40 BUSINESS AND COMPETITION</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100229</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100229</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>4021</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>4021 management</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <WORK_ID_DOCUMENT type="data">
                  <VALUE>celex:32012R0447</VALUE>
               </WORK_ID_DOCUMENT>
               <WORK_CREATED_BY_AGENT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/corporate-body/COM</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>COM</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>corporate-body</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>COM</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>COM</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>European Commission</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Commission of the European Communities</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>European Commission</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Commission</ALTLABEL>
               </WORK_CREATED_BY_AGENT>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_ID_CELEX type="data">
                  <VALUE>32012R0447</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_ID_CELEX>
               <WORK_TABLE-OF-CONTENTS type="data">
                  <VALUE>
         &lt;table-of-contents&gt;
            &lt;p&gt;0014 - 0016&lt;/p&gt;
         &lt;/table-of-contents&gt;
      </VALUE>
               </WORK_TABLE-OF-CONTENTS>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_ELI type="data">
                  <VALUE>http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2012/447/oj</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_ELI>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_PUBLISHED_IN_SPECIAL-OFFICIAL-JOURNAL type="link">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/64c04f98-d4da-11e2-bfa7-01aa75ed71a1</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>64c04f98-d4da-11e2-bfa7-01aa75ed71a1</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/DD_2013_06_009_HR</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>DD_2013_06_009_HR</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/uriserv/DD.HRV.06.009.FULL</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>DD.HRV.06.009.FULL</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>uriserv</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_PUBLISHED_IN_SPECIAL-OFFICIAL-JOURNAL>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_TYPE type="data">
                  <VALUE>R</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_TYPE>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/06202080</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>06202080</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>fd_555</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>06202080</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>06202080</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>Other service activities</PREFLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IN-FORCE type="data">
                  <VALUE>true</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IN-FORCE>
               <LASTMODIFICATIONDATE type="date">
                  <VALUE>2016-08-16T19:28:57.309+02:00</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2016</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>08</MONTH>
                  <DAY>16</DAY>
               </LASTMODIFICATIONDATE>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_YEAR type="data">
                  <VALUE>2012</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_YEAR>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_NUMBER_NATURAL type="data">
                  <VALUE>447</VALUE>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_NUMBER_NATURAL>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE type="concept_level">
                  <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_4 type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/06202080</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>06202080</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>fd_555</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <OP-CODE>06202080</OP-CODE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>06202080</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>Other service activities</PREFLABEL>
                  </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_4>
                  <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_1 type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/06</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>06</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>fd_555</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <OP-CODE>06</OP-CODE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>06</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>Right of establishment and freedom to provide services</PREFLABEL>
                  </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_1>
                  <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_2 type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/0620</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>0620</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>fd_555</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <OP-CODE>0620</OP-CODE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>0620</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>Sectoral application</PREFLABEL>
                  </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_2>
                  <RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_3 type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_555/062020</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>062020</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>fd_555</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <OP-CODE>062020</OP-CODE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>062020</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>Service activities</PREFLABEL>
                  </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE_3>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_DIRECTORY-CODE>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/6263</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6263</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>6263</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>evaluation method</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>evaluation</ALTLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5769</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>5769</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>5769</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>EU office or agency</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>specialised Community agency</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>European Union office or agency</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>EC specialised body</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>European agency</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>European Monitoring Centre</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>EC institutional body</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Community service body</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>EC satellite body</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>EU Agencies and decentralised bodies</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>European foundation</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>decentralised Community body</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>autonomous Community body</ALTLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/2616</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>2616</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>2616</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>economic forecasting</PREFLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>economic projection</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>economic prospects</ALTLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/2616</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>2616</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>2616</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>economic forecasting</PREFLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>economic projection</ALTLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>economic prospects</ALTLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100146</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100146</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>16</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>16 ECONOMICS</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100190</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100190</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>1631</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>1631 economic analysis</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <YEAR type="data">
                  <VALUE>2012</VALUE>
               </YEAR>
               <WORK_HAS_RESOURCE-TYPE type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/resource-type/REG_DEL</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>REG_DEL</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>resource-type</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>REG_DEL</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>REG_DEL</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>Delegated regulation</PREFLABEL>
               </WORK_HAS_RESOURCE-TYPE>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/4675</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>4675</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <IDENTIFIER>4675</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>auditing</PREFLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC type="concept_facet">
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/5945</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>5945</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>5945</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>administrative supervision</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_CONCEPT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/77</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>77</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>77</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>public administration</PREFLABEL>
                     <ALTLABEL>general government</ALTLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_TT>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100142</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100142</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>04</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>04 POLITICS</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_DOM>
                  <WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH type="concept">
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://eurovoc.europa.eu/100169</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>100169</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>EUROVOC</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                     <IDENTIFIER>0436</IDENTIFIER>
                     <PREFLABEL>0436 executive power and public service</PREFLABEL>
                  </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC_MTH>
               </WORK_IS_ABOUT_CONCEPT_EUROVOC>
               <RESOURCE_LEGAL_BASED_ON_CONCEPT_TREATY type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/treaty/TFEU_2008</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>TFEU_2008</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>treaty</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>TFEU_2008</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>TFEU_2008</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (consolidated version 2008)</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>TFEU (2008)</ALTLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>Consolidated version of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (2008)</ALTLABEL>
               </RESOURCE_LEGAL_BASED_ON_CONCEPT_TREATY>
               <WORK_CITES_WORK type="link">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/d6206116-a910-4ffa-b6cd-f14b1b503568</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>d6206116-a910-4ffa-b6cd-f14b1b503568</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/JOL_2010_331_R_0084_01</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>JOL_2010_331_R_0084_01</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/celex/32010R1095</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>32010R1095</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>celex</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/eli/reg/2010/1095/oj</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>reg:2010:1095:oj</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>eli</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
               </WORK_CITES_WORK>
               <IS_ABOUT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/fd_070/MARI</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>MARI</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>fd_070</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>MARI</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>MARI</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>Internal market - Principles</PREFLABEL>
               </IS_ABOUT>
               <WORK_PART_OF_COLLECTION_DOCUMENT type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/document-collection/CELEX</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>CELEX</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>document-collection</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>CELEX</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>CELEX</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>CELEX</PREFLABEL>
               </WORK_PART_OF_COLLECTION_DOCUMENT>
               <IDENTIFIER type="data">
                  <VALUE>oj:JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01</VALUE>
               </IDENTIFIER>
               <ID_CELEX type="data">
                  <VALUE>32012R0447</VALUE>
               </ID_CELEX>
               <DATE_CREATION_LEGACY type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-05-30</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>05</MONTH>
                  <DAY>30</DAY>
               </DATE_CREATION_LEGACY>
               <WORK_DATE_DOCUMENT type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-03-21</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>03</MONTH>
                  <DAY>21</DAY>
               </WORK_DATE_DOCUMENT>
               <IDENTIFIER type="data">
                  <VALUE>http://data.europa.eu/eli/reg_del/2012/447/oj</VALUE>
               </IDENTIFIER>
               <DATE type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-03-21</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>03</MONTH>
                  <DAY>21</DAY>
               </DATE>
               <BASED_ON type="link">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/6e35c7f1-c976-4c9f-83d9-f5919e956de0</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>6e35c7f1-c976-4c9f-83d9-f5919e956de0</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/eli/reg/2009/1060/oj</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>reg:2009:1060:oj</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>eli</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/JOL_2009_302_R_0001_01</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>JOL_2009_302_R_0001_01</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
                  <SAMEAS>
                     <URI>
                        <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/celex/32009R1060</VALUE>
                        <IDENTIFIER>32009R1060</IDENTIFIER>
                        <TYPE>celex</TYPE>
                     </URI>
                  </SAMEAS>
               </BASED_ON>
               <DATE type="date">
                  <VALUE>2012-06-19</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2012</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>06</MONTH>
                  <DAY>19</DAY>
               </DATE>
               <TYPE>cdm:regulation_delegated</TYPE>
               <TYPE>cdm:legislation_secondary</TYPE>
               <TYPE>cdm:resource_legal</TYPE>
               <TYPE>R</TYPE>
               <TYPE>cdm:regulation</TYPE>
               <TYPE>cdm:work</TYPE>
            </WORK>
            <EXPRESSION xmlns="">
               <URI>
                  <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/cellar/d24a8a3e-5125-4547-b352-d840929bedbc.0009</VALUE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>d24a8a3e-5125-4547-b352-d840929bedbc.0009</IDENTIFIER>
                  <TYPE>cellar</TYPE>
               </URI>
               <SAMEAS>
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/uriserv/OJ.L_.2012.140.01.0014.01.ENG</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>OJ.L_.2012.140.01.0014.01.ENG</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>uriserv</TYPE>
                  </URI>
               </SAMEAS>
               <SAMEAS>
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/celex/32012R0447.ENG</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>32012R0447.ENG</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>celex</TYPE>
                  </URI>
               </SAMEAS>
               <SAMEAS>
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/oj/JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01.ENG</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>JOL_2012_140_R_0014_01.ENG</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>oj</TYPE>
                  </URI>
               </SAMEAS>
               <TITLE type="data">
                  <VALUE>CELEX1</VALUE>
               </TITLE>
               <TITLE type="data">
                  <VALUE>Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012 of 21 March 2012 supplementing Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on credit rating agencies by laying down regulatory technical standards for the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies  Text with EEA relevance</VALUE>
               </TITLE>
               <LANG type="data">
                  <VALUE>eng</VALUE>
               </LANG>
               <EXPRESSION_USES_LANGUAGE type="concept">
                  <URI>
                     <VALUE>http://publications.europa.eu/resource/authority/language/ENG</VALUE>
                     <IDENTIFIER>ENG</IDENTIFIER>
                     <TYPE>language</TYPE>
                  </URI>
                  <OP-CODE>ENG</OP-CODE>
                  <IDENTIFIER>ENG</IDENTIFIER>
                  <PREFLABEL>English</PREFLABEL>
                  <ALTLABEL>English</ALTLABEL>
               </EXPRESSION_USES_LANGUAGE>
               <LASTMODIFICATIONDATE type="date">
                  <VALUE>2016-03-15T15:08:25.806+01:00</VALUE>
                  <YEAR>2016</YEAR>
                  <MONTH>03</MONTH>
                  <DAY>15</DAY>
               </LASTMODIFICATIONDATE>
               <EXPRESSION_TITLE type="data">
                  <VALUE>Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012 of 21 March 2012 supplementing Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on credit rating agencies by laying down regulatory technical standards for the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies  Text with EEA relevance</VALUE>
               </EXPRESSION_TITLE>
               <LANG type="data">
                  <VALUE>en</VALUE>
               </LANG>
            </EXPRESSION>
         </ukm:EURLexMetadata><ukm:DocumentCurrentStatus><ukm:UKAmended Value="true"/></ukm:DocumentCurrentStatus><ukm:UnappliedEffects><ukm:UnappliedEffect AffectingYear="2023" Row="749" AffectedProvisions="Regulation" AffectedURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447" EffectId="key-fac308b3ffa7a1059ecb9c18106039b6" AffectingNumber="29" Comments="made under Regulation 2009/924 Sch. 1 Pt. 1 Researched using EU Publications Office data" AffectingURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29" AffectedNumber="447" AffectedYear="2012" AffectingProvisions="Sch. 1 Pt. 1 3" AffectedClass="EuropeanUnionRegulation" Type="revoked" AffectingClass="UnitedKingdomPublicGeneralAct" RequiresApplied="true" Modified="2026-03-02T11:20:22Z" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/effect/key-fac308b3ffa7a1059ecb9c18106039b6"><ukm:AffectedTitle>Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) No 447/2012 of 21 March 2012 supplementing Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on credit rating agencies by laying down regulatory technical standards for the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies (Text with EEA relevance)</ukm:AffectedTitle><ukm:AffectedProvisions>Regulation</ukm:AffectedProvisions><ukm:AffectingTitle>Financial Services and Markets Act 2023</ukm:AffectingTitle><ukm:AffectingProvisions><ukm:Section Ref="schedule-1" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/schedule/1">Sch. 1 </ukm:Section><ukm:Section Ref="schedule-1-part-1" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/schedule/1/part/1">Pt. 1</ukm:Section> <ukm:Section Ref="schedule-1-part-3" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/schedule/1/part/3">3</ukm:Section></ukm:AffectingProvisions><ukm:Savings><ukm:Section Ref="section-1-4" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/section/1/4">s. 1(4)</ukm:Section></ukm:Savings><ukm:CommencementAuthority><ukm:Section Ref="section-86-3" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/section/86/3">s. 86(3)</ukm:Section></ukm:CommencementAuthority><ukm:InForceDates><ukm:InForce Applied="false" Prospective="true" Qualification=""/></ukm:InForceDates></ukm:UnappliedEffect></ukm:UnappliedEffects></ukm:EUMetadata>
					

                    
									 
					<ukm:Alternatives><ukm:Alternative URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/pdfs/eur_20120447_adopted_en.pdf" Date="2012-05-30" Size="737006"/> </ukm:Alternatives>
					
					<ukm:Statistics>
									<ukm:TotalParagraphs Value="9"/>
									<ukm:BodyParagraphs Value="9"/>
									<ukm:ScheduleParagraphs Value="0"/>
									<ukm:AttachmentParagraphs Value="0"/>
									<ukm:TotalImages Value="0"/>
								</ukm:Statistics>
				</ukm:Metadata><EURetained>
      <EUPrelims DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/introduction" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/introduction" RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2023-07-11">
         <MultilineTitle>
            <Text>
               <Uppercase>Commission Delegated Regulation</Uppercase> (EU) No 447/2012</Text>
            <Text>of 21 March 2012</Text>
            <Text>supplementing Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on credit rating agencies by laying down regulatory technical standards for the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies</Text>
            <Text>(Text with EEA relevance)</Text>
         </MultilineTitle>
         <EUPreamble><CommentaryRef Ref="key-ac5ba7a7b256c59ddb9d8bfa58918de2"/><CommentaryRef Ref="key-2bfc19a49ea69d2bddf27aede3042265"/>
            <P>
               <Text>THE EUROPEAN COMMISSION,</Text>
            </P>
            <P>
               <Text>Having regard to the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union,</Text>
            </P>
            <P>
               <Text>Having regard to Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 16 September 2009 on credit rating agencies<FootnoteRef Ref="f00001"/>, and in particular point (d) of Article 21(4) thereof,</Text>
            </P>
            <P>
               <Text>Whereas:</Text>
            </P>
            <Division>
               <Number>(1)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 requires a credit rating agency to use credit rating methodologies that are rigorous, systematic, continuous and subject to validation based on historical experience, including back-testing.</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <Division>
               <Number>(2)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>This Regulation is necessary to ensure transparency in the assessment carried out by the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) established by Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010 of the European Parliament and the Council of 24 November 2010 establishing a European Supervisory Authority (European Securities and Markets Authority), amending Decision No 716/2009/EC and repealing Commission Decision 2009/77/EC<FootnoteRef Ref="f00002"/> and uniform rules regarding the requirements set out in Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009.</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <Division>
               <Number>(3)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>ESMA has to assess the compliance of credit rating agencies with the provision of Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 when examining applications for registration pursuant to Article 15 of that Regulation. After the registration ESMA should assess as part of its ongoing supervision the continuous compliance of credit rating agencies with the provision of Article 8(3) whenever it considers such assessment necessary.</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <Division>
               <Number>(4)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009, in particular Article 23 thereof, does not permit ESMA, the Commission or any public authorities of a Member State to interfere with the content of credit ratings or methodologies. Accordingly, this Regulation should lay down the rules by which those methodologies are to be assessed but should not provide for those authorities to decide on the accuracy of a credit rating produced by those methodologies.</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <Division>
               <Number>(5)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>Article 6(2) when read in conjunction with point 9 of Section A of Annex I to Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 requires a credit rating agency to establish a review function responsible for periodically reviewing its methodologies, models and key rating assumptions, such as mathematical or correlation assumptions, and any significant changes or modifications thereto as well as the appropriateness of those methodologies, models and key rating assumptions where they are used or intended to be used for the assessment of new financial instruments.</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <Division>
               <Number>(6)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>This Regulation is based on the draft regulatory technical standards submitted by ESMA to the Commission for endorsement by the Commission pursuant to the procedure laid down in Article 10 of Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010.</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <Division>
               <Number>(7)</Number>
               <P>
                  <Text>ESMA has conducted open public consultations on the draft regulatory technical standards on which this Regulation is based, analysed the potential related costs and benefits and requested the opinion of the Securities and Markets Stakeholder Group established under Article 37 of Regulation (EU) No 1095/2010. In addition, ESMA has launched a call for evidence in May 2011 in order to gather information from market participants,</Text>
               </P>
            </Division>
            <P>
               <Text>HAS ADOPTED THIS REGULATION:</Text>
            </P>
         </EUPreamble>
      </EUPrelims>
      <EUBody DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/body" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/body" NumberOfProvisions="9" RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Subject matter</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/1" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/1" id="article-1">
               <Pnumber>Article 1</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <Text>This Regulation lays down the rules to be used in the assessment of compliance of credit rating methodologies with the requirements set out in Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009.</Text>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Demonstration of compliance</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/2" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/2" id="article-2">
               <Pnumber>Article 2</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <Text>A credit rating agency shall at all times be able to demonstrate to ESMA its compliance with the requirements set out in Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 relating to the use of credit rating methodologies.</Text>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Assessment of compliance by ESMA</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/3" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/3" id="article-3">
               <Pnumber>Article 3</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/3/1" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/3/1" id="article-3-1">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">1</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>In addition to examining the compliance of credit rating agencies with the provision of Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 in relation to an application for registration according to Article 15 of that Regulation, ESMA shall examine compliance by each credit rating agency with Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 on an ongoing basis as ESMA considers appropriate.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/3/2" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/3/2" id="article-3-2">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">2</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>When examining the compliance of credit rating agencies with the provision of Article 8(3) of Regulation (EC) No 1060/2009 ESMA shall use all information relevant to assess the process of developing, approving, using and reviewing credit rating methodologies.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/3/3" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/3/3" id="article-3-3">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">3</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>In determining the appropriate level of assessment, ESMA shall consider whether a credit rating methodology has a demonstrable history of consistency and accuracy in predicting credit worthiness and may have regard to methods of validation such as appropriate default or transition studies designed to test that specific methodology.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Assessing that a credit rating methodology is rigorous</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/4" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/4" id="article-4">
               <Pnumber>Article 4</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/4/1" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/4/1" id="article-4-1">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">1</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall use and apply credit rating methodologies which:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>contain clear and robust controls and processes for their developments and related approvals that allow suitable challenge;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>incorporate all driving factors deemed relevant in determining creditworthiness of a rated entity or a financial instrument which shall be supported by statistical, historical experience or evidence;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">c</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>consider the modelled relationship between rated entities or financial instruments of the same risk factor and risk factors to which the credit rating methodologies are sensitive;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">d</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>incorporate reliable, relevant and quality related analytical models, key credit rating assumptions and criteria where these are in place.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/4/2" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/4/2" id="article-4-2">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">2</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall list and provide a detailed explanation of the following points with regard to the credit rating methodologies used regarding:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>each qualitative factor, including the scope of qualitative judgement for that factor;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>each quantitative factor, including key variables, data sources, key assumptions, modelling and quantitative techniques.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/4/3" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/4/3" id="article-4-3">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">3</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>The detailed explanation referred to in paragraph 2 shall include the following:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>a statement of the importance of each qualitative or quantitative factor used within that credit rating methodology including, where relevant, a description of and justification for related weightings assigned to those factors and their impact on credit ratings;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>an assessment of the relationship between the key assumptions used in that credit rating methodology and the critical risk factors derived from macroeconomic or financial data; and</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">c</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>an assessment of the relationship between the key assumptions used in credit rating methodology and the volatility of credit ratings produced by that methodology over time.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/4/4" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/4/4" id="article-4-4">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">4</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall use credit rating methodologies and their associated analytical models, key credit rating assumptions and criteria that promptly incorporate findings or outcomes from an internal review or a monitoring review undertaken by one or more of the following:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>the credit rating agency’s independent members of the administrative or supervisory board;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>the credit rating agency’s review function;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">c</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>any other relevant person or committee involved in the monitoring and reviewing of credit rating methodologies.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Assessing that a credit rating methodology is systematic</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/5" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/5" id="article-5">
               <Pnumber>Article 5</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/5/1" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/5/1" id="article-5-1">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">1</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall use a credit rating methodology and its associated analytical models, key credit rating assumptions and criteria that are applied systematically in the formulation of all credit ratings in a given asset class or market segment unless there is an objective reason for diverging from it.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/5/2" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/5/2" id="article-5-2">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">2</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall use a credit rating methodology which is capable of promptly incorporating the findings from any review of its appropriateness.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Assessing that a credit rating methodology is continuous</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/6" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/6" id="article-6">
               <Pnumber>Article 6</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <Text>A credit rating agency shall use credit rating methodologies shall that are designed and implemented in a way that enables them to:</Text>
               </P1para>
               <P1para>
                  <OrderedList Type="alpha" Decoration="parens">
                     <ListItem NumberOverride="(a)">
                        <Para>
                           <Text>continue to be used unless there is an objective reason for the credit rating methodology to change or be discontinued;</Text>
                        </Para>
                     </ListItem>
                     <ListItem NumberOverride="(b)">
                        <Para>
                           <Text>be capable of promptly incorporating any finding from ongoing monitoring or a review, in particular where changes in structural macroeconomic or financial market conditions would be capable of affecting credit ratings produced by that methodology;</Text>
                        </Para>
                     </ListItem>
                     <ListItem NumberOverride="(c)">
                        <Para>
                           <Text>compare credit ratings across different asset classes.</Text>
                        </Para>
                     </ListItem>
                  </OrderedList>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Assessing that a credit rating methodology is subject to validation based on historical experience including back testing</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/7" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/7" id="article-7">
               <Pnumber>Article 7</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/7/1" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/7/1" id="article-7-1">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">1</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall use credit ratings methodologies that are supported by quantitative evidence of the discriminatory power of the credit rating methodology.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/7/2" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/7/2" id="article-7-2">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">2</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall use credit rating methodologies that describe the following:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>the historical robustness and predictive power of credit ratings issued using the relevant methodology over appropriate time horizons and across different asset classes;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>the degree to which the assumptions used in the rating model deviate from the actual default and loss rates.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/7/3" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/7/3" id="article-7-3">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">3</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>The validation of a credit rating methodology shall be designed to:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>examine the sensitivity of a credit rating methodology to changes in any of its underlying assumptions, including qualitative or quantitative factors;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>perform an adequate and appropriate assessment of historic credit ratings produced by means of that credit rating methodology;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">c</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>use reliable inputs, including appropriate size of the data samples;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">d</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>take appropriate account of the main geographical areas of the rated entities or financial instruments for each of the credit rating categories rated such as structured finance, sovereign, corporates, financial institutions, insurances, public finance.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/7/4" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/7/4" id="article-7-4">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">4</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>A credit rating agency shall have processes in place to ensure that systemic credit rating anomalies highlighted by back-testing are identified and are appropriately addressed.</Text>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
                  <P2 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/7/5" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/7/5" id="article-7-5">
                     <Pnumber PuncBefore="" PuncAfter=".">5</Pnumber>
                     <P2para>
                        <Text>In the process of reviewing credit rating methodologies, a credit rating agency shall include:</Text>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">a</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>regular credit rating and performance reviews on rated entities and financial instruments;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">b</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>in-sample and out-of-sample testing;</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                        <P3>
                           <Pnumber PuncBefore="(" PuncAfter=")">c</Pnumber>
                           <P3para>
                              <Text>historic information on validation or back-testing.</Text>
                           </P3para>
                        </P3>
                     </P2para>
                  </P2>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Exemption</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/8" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/8" id="article-8">
               <Pnumber>Article 8</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <Text>In cases where there is limited quantitative evidence to support the predictive power of a credit rating methodology, a credit rating agency shall be exempt from complying with Article 7 of this Regulation if it:</Text>
               </P1para>
               <P1para>
                  <OrderedList Type="alpha" Decoration="parens">
                     <ListItem NumberOverride="(a)">
                        <Para>
                           <Text>ensures that credit rating methodologies are sensible predictors of credit worthiness;</Text>
                        </Para>
                     </ListItem>
                     <ListItem NumberOverride="(b)">
                        <Para>
                           <Text>applies internal procedures in a consistent way and over time and across different market segments;</Text>
                        </Para>
                     </ListItem>
                     <ListItem NumberOverride="(c)">
                        <Para>
                           <Text>has processes in place to ensure that systemic credit rating anomalies highlighted by back-testing are identified and are appropriately addressed.</Text>
                        </Para>
                     </ListItem>
                  </OrderedList>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <P1group RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Title>Entry into force</Title>
            <P1 DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/article/9" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/article/9" id="article-9">
               <Pnumber>Article 9</Pnumber>
               <P1para>
                  <Text>This Regulation shall enter into force on the twentieth day following that of its publication in the <Emphasis>Official Journal of the European Union.</Emphasis>
                  </Text>
               </P1para>
            </P1>
         </P1group>
         <SignedSection DocumentURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/eur/2012/447/signature" IdURI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/eur/2012/447/signature" RestrictExtent="E+W+S+N.I." RestrictStartDate="2012-03-21">
            <Para>
               <Text>This Regulation shall be binding in its entirety and directly applicable in all Member States.</Text>
            </Para>
            <Signatory>
               <Para>
                  <Text>Done at Brussels, 21 March 2012.</Text>
               </Para>
               <Signee>
                  <Para>
                     <Text>
                        <Emphasis>For the Commission</Emphasis>
                     </Text>
                  </Para>
                  <Para>
                     <Text>
                        <Emphasis>The President</Emphasis>
                     </Text>
                  </Para>
                  <Para>
                     <Text>José Manuel <Uppercase>Barroso</Uppercase>
                     </Text>
                  </Para>
               </Signee>
            </Signatory>
         </SignedSection>
      </EUBody>
   </EURetained><Footnotes><Footnote id="f00001">
         <FootnoteText>
            <Para>
               <Text>
                  <Citation id="c00001" Class="EuropeanUnionOfficialJournal" Year="2009" URI="https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/eu-exit/https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=uriserv:OJ.L_.2009.302.01.0001.01.ENG" Date="2009-11-17">OJ L 302, 17.11.2009, p. 1</Citation>.</Text>
            </Para>
         </FootnoteText>
      </Footnote><Footnote id="f00002">
         <FootnoteText>
            <Para>
               <Text>
                  <Citation id="c00002" Class="EuropeanUnionOfficialJournal" Year="2010" URI="https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/eu-exit/https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=uriserv:OJ.L_.2010.331.01.0084.01.ENG" Date="2010-12-15">OJ L 331, 15.12.2010, p. 84</Citation>.</Text>
            </Para>
         </FootnoteText>
      </Footnote></Footnotes><Commentaries><Commentary id="key-ac5ba7a7b256c59ddb9d8bfa58918de2" Type="C"><Para><Text>The “appropriate regulator” has power to make such provision as they consider appropriate by means of an instrument in writing to prevent, remedy or mitigate any failure of the provisions of this Regulation to operate effectively or any other deficiency arising from the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the EU, see <Citation id="c7g29p995-00005" Class="UnitedKingdomStatutoryInstrument" Year="2018" Number="1115" Title="The Financial Regulators' Powers (Technical Standards etc.) (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2018">The Financial Regulators' Powers (Technical Standards etc.) (Amendment etc.) (EU Exit) Regulations 2018 (S.I. 2018/1115)</Citation>, <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00005" SectionRef="regulation-2" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2018/1115/regulation/2" id="c7g29p995-00006">regs. 2</CitationSubRef>, <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00005" SectionRef="regulation-3" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2018/1115/regulation/3" id="c7g29p995-00007">3</CitationSubRef>, <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00005" SectionRef="schedule-part-1" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2018/1115/schedule/part/1" id="c7g29p995-00008">Sch. Pt. 1</CitationSubRef> (with saving on <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00005" SectionRef="schedule-part-I" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2018/1115/schedule/part/I" id="c7g29p995-00009">I</CitationSubRef>P completion day by <Citation id="c7g29p995-00010" Class="UnitedKingdomStatutoryInstrument" Year="2019" Number="680">S.I. 2019/680</Citation>, <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00010" SectionRef="regulation-1-2" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2019/680/regulation/1/2" id="c7g29p995-00011">regs. 1(2)</CitationSubRef>, <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00010" SectionRef="regulation-11" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2019/680/regulation/11" id="c7g29p995-00012">11</CitationSubRef>; <Citation id="c7g29p995-00013" Year="2020" Class="UnitedKingdomPublicGeneralAct" Number="1">2020 c. 1</Citation>, <CitationSubRef CitationRef="c7g29p995-00013" SectionRef="schedule-5-paragraph-1-1" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2020/1/schedule/5/paragraph/1/1" id="c7g29p995-00014">Sch. 5 para. 1(1)</CitationSubRef>)</Text></Para></Commentary><Commentary id="key-2bfc19a49ea69d2bddf27aede3042265" Type="C"><Para><Text>Regulation: power to modify conferred (11.7.2023) by <Citation URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29" Class="UnitedKingdomPublicGeneralAct" Year="2023" Number="29" Title="Financial Services and Markets Act 2023" id="c7g31asp5-00007">Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 (c. 29)</Citation>, <CitationSubRef SectionRef="section-3" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/section/3" CitationRef="c7g31asp5-00007" id="c7g31asp5-00008">ss. 3</CitationSubRef>, <CitationSubRef SectionRef="section-86-3" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/section/86/3" CitationRef="c7g31asp5-00007" id="c7g31asp5-00009">86(3)</CitationSubRef>, <CitationSubRef SectionRef="schedule-1-part-1" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/schedule/1/part/1" CitationRef="c7g31asp5-00007" id="c7g31asp5-00010">Sch. 1 Pts. 1</CitationSubRef>, <CitationSubRef SectionRef="schedule-1-part-3" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/ukpga/2023/29/schedule/1/part/3" CitationRef="c7g31asp5-00007" Operative="true" id="c7g31asp5-00011">3</CitationSubRef>; <Citation URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2023/779" Class="UnitedKingdomStatutoryInstrument" Year="2023" Number="779" Title="The Financial Services and Markets Act 2023 (Commencement No. 1) Regulations 2023" id="c7g31asp5-00012">S.I. 2023/779</Citation>, <CitationSubRef SectionRef="regulation-2-d" URI="http://www.legislation.gov.uk/id/uksi/2023/779/regulation/2/d" CitationRef="c7g31asp5-00012" id="c7g31asp5-00013">reg. 2(d)</CitationSubRef></Text></Para></Commentary></Commentaries></Legislation>