- Latest available (Revised)
- Original (As adopted by EU)
When the UK left the EU, legislation.gov.uk published EU legislation that had been published by the EU up to IP completion day (31 December 2020 11.00 p.m.). On legislation.gov.uk, these items of legislation are kept up-to-date with any amendments made by the UK since then.
Legislation.gov.uk publishes the UK version. EUR-Lex publishes the EU version. The EU Exit Web Archive holds a snapshot of EUR-Lex’s version from IP completion day (31 December 2020 11.00 p.m.).
This is the original version as it was originally adopted in the EU.
This legislation may since have been updated - see the latest available (revised) version
THE COMMISSION OF THE EUROPEAN COMMUNITIES,
Having regard to the Treaty establishing the European Community, and in particular the first subparagraph of Article 88(2) thereof,
Having regard to the Agreement on the European Economic Area, and in particular Article 62(1)(a) thereof,
Having called on interested parties to submit their comments pursuant to those provisions(1) and having regard to their comments,
Whereas:
I. PROCEDURE
II. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE MEASURE
| Establishment | Type of initial investment | Investment period | Number of newly created jobs | Amount of investment in nominal value(in SKK 000) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Veľký Grob | Rationalisation Extension of an existing establishment | 2007, 2008 | — | 26 400 |
| Veľký Cetín | Modernisation | 2007 | — | 9 000 |
| Komjatice | Modernisation | 2008 | — | 10 200 |
| Kamenec pod Vtáčnikom | Modernisation Diversification | 2007, 2008 2010, 2011 | 27 | 151 000 |
| Hontianske Trsťany — Hrondín | Diversification | 2008, 2009 | 20 | 49 000 |
| Červeník | Setting-up of a new establishment | 2007, 2009 | 16 | 40 000 |
| Okoč | Setting-up of a new establishment | 2007 | 14 | 29 000 |
| Nitra | Diversification | 2008 | — | 14 000 |
| Prievidza | Setting-up of a new establishment | 2009, 2010 | 4 | 51 000 |
| Total | 81 | 379 600 |
III. GROUNDS FOR INITIATING THE PROCEDURE
First, the Commission had doubts as to whether the limitation of regional investment aid to initial investment, as laid down in point 4.4 of the RAG 1998, was respected. According to point 4.4 of RAG 1998, initial investment is defined as an investment in fixed capital relating to the setting-up of a new establishment, the extension of an existing establishment or the starting-up of an activity involving a fundamental change in the product or production process of an existing establishment (through rationalisation, diversification or modernisation). This definition excludes from its scope replacement investment. Aid to replacement investment is to be considered as operating aid, which is allowed only if specific conditions are met (cf. points 4.15, 4.16 and 4.17 of RAG 1998).
It appeared that in at least three establishments (Veľký Grob, Veľký Cetín and Kamenec pod Vtáčnikom) the beneficiary is purchasing the same type of machinery/equipment as it currently uses and rents. The improved quality of the purchased equipment or the significant increase in the production concerned may be questioned, although the beneficiary claimed that new equipment would be more modern than the one currently leased.
At its Nitra establishment, the beneficiary will offer its customers only a ‘complementary’ service in order to ‘maintain the company’s market share, cash flow and economic results’(13). It seemed difficult to justify aid in a situation where no additional activity is to be carried out.
Second, the measure at issue constitutes individual aid, to be granted to a company active in a specific sector of extraction of raw materials. Consequently, this aid measure is to be considered selective with a greater impact on other companies active in the same sector. According to point 2 of RAG 1998, an individual ad hoc aid made to a single firm, or confined to one area of activity, may have a major impact on competition in the relevant market, and its effects on regional development are likely to be fairly limited. Such aid generally comes within the scope of specific sectoral industrial policies and is not in line with the spirit of regional aid policy as such. The latter must remain neutral towards the allocation of productive resources between the various economic sectors and activities. In conclusion, the RAG 1998 take a negative stance towards individual aid measures unless it can be proved that the regional contribution of the aid outweighs the distortion of competition and the effects on trade. In this case, the Commission had doubts whether the limited contribution to regional development can justify the relatively high amount of aid per job created.
It transpires from the information submitted that only 81 direct jobs would be newly created, whereas some 57 direct jobs created by the beneficiary in the past would be maintained by the aided investments. The new jobs would concern only five of the nine establishments of the project (see table above). The Commission noted that 34 out of the 81 newly created jobs should be created in the three new establishments envisaged(14). Consequently, the Commission had doubts as to whether the relatively high amount of aid per direct job created, in particular in a low wage sector (the aid per direct job created would correspond to around seven annual salaries), was justified.
Concerning the number of indirect jobs, in their letter dated 17 February 2007 the Slovak authorities initially indicated that 100 indirect jobs would be created. Later on, in their second letter of 4 June 2007 providing additional information, they referred to the statistics of the European Aggregates Association, claiming that indirect jobs would amount to 414-690. According to this study, in the sector in which the company is pursuing its business activities, approximately 3-5 jobs are created in respect of each newly created job. In the information submission dated 13 August 2007, the Slovak authorities referred finally to a survey furnished to Alas by the University of Leoben (Austria), according to which in the sector of processing of raw materials, each new direct job corresponds to 30-40 indirect jobs(15). The Commission had doubts as to whether this general statement on mineral extraction was transferable to the situation of building materials.
Moreover, the aid is granted to activities in the extraction industry whose location is determined not by the granting of aid, but by the availability of minerals; this is less affected by the regional handicaps that normally hamper regional development. Consequently, it can be assumed that it would be possible to exploit the resources even without the aid. In addition, since Alas was already operating in most of the establishments on the basis of long-term licences, the incentive effect of additional regional aid was doubtful.
Third, the likely limited contribution to regional development has to be balanced against the effect on trade and distortion of competition of the aid measure which, according to the Slovak authorities, is also expected to be small. The selling radius of the products concerned is limited (approximately 50 km by road or 150 km by rail) owing to their relatively small value with regard to the cost of transport. The Slovak authorities indicated that only one establishment (Hontianske Trsťany — Hrondín) would be in a position to export part of its production (up to 50 thousand tonnes of building stone annually worth SKK 9 million) to Hungary. Three other establishments (Veľký Cetín, Okoč and Komjatice) are expected to compete with imports from Hungary. Alas Slovakia, s.r.o. does not expect to compete with other companies mining and processing minerals from Austria or the Czech Republic. However, this seemed to be in contradiction with the information contained in the application for the first part of the aid, submitted to the Slovak authorities on 16 April 2003, where potential competitors from these two countries were mentioned.
Taking into account the location of the establishments concerned, the Commission had doubts about the extent to which trade with other Member States (e.g. Austria or the Czech Republic) would be distorted.
Finally, as laid down in the Commission notice on the definition of the relevant market for the purposes of Community competition law(16), in certain cases, even if the deliveries from a given plant are limited to a certain area around that plant, the distribution of plants may be such that the areas around the different plants overlap significantly. If so, it is possible that the pricing of those products would be affected by a chain substitution effect, leading to impacts on a broader geographic market.
As a result, the Commission had doubts as to whether the expected contribution of the aid to regional development would offset its negative effects on trade.
IV. COMMENTS FROM THE SLOVAK REPUBLIC AND INTERESTED PARTIES
V. ASSESSMENT OF THE MEASURE
VI. CONCLUSION
HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION:
The notified tax concession constitutes State aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty.
The State aid which the Slovak Republic is planning to implement for Alas Slovakia, s.r.o. for up to SKK 100 813 444 (approximately EUR 2,89 million) is not compatible with the common market.
In view of this, the aid may not be implemented.
The Slovak Republic shall inform the Commission, within two months of notification of this Decision, of the measures taken to comply with the Decision.
This Decision is addressed to the Slovak Republic.
Done at Brussels, 4 June 2008.
For the Commission
Neelie Kroes
Member of the Commission
By letter dated 13 February 2006, the Commission asked the Slovak authorities to submit for evaluation nine different notifications so that it could assess the compatibility of each of the nine projects on the basis of their individual merits. In their reply of 12 March 2007, the Slovak authorities explained to the Commission that Alas Slovakia s.r.o., constituted a single tax entity with several establishments, with a single tax liability. The applicable Slovak legislation does not allow taxpayers to calculate the tax base and the corporate tax for each organisational unit separately. Therefore, the Slovak authorities consider that it is not possible to calculate the amount of aid received by each establishment.
See footnote 1.
In the municipalities of: Nitra, Komjatice, Veľký Cetín, Hontianske Trsťany-Hrondín.
In the municipalities of: Červeník, Veľký Grob, Okoč.
In the municipalities of: Kamenec pod Vtáčnikom, Prievidza.
State aid SK 72/2003 — Slovak Republic — ‘Regional State aid map of the Slovak Republic’.
Expressed at 2007 value and calculated at a reference rate of 5,62 % applicable on the date of the notification.
By notification No 1108/2003 of the Slovak Office for State Aid, issued on 25 August 2003, State aid was approved for Alas Slovakia, s.r.o. (2003 to 2012), in accordance with Section 35a of Act No 472/2002, as amended, and Act No 366/1999, for a maximum level of SKK 87 145 485. Under the interim procedure, this State aid (SK 53/03) was considered ‘existing aid’.
Act No 231/1999 Coll. on State aid, as amended, Act No 595/2003 Coll. on income tax, as amended, and Act No 366/1999 Coll. on income taxes, as amended, as in force on 31 December 2003, in particular Section 52(3) of Act No 595/2003 Coll. on income tax, as amended, under the conditions specified in Section 35a of Act No 366/1999 Coll. on income taxes, as amended, as in force on 31 December 2003.
Letter from the Slovak Ministry of Finance, dated 31 May 2007 (ref. MF/8790/2007-832).
In this respect, it should be underlined that 16 new jobs out of 81 should be created at the site of Červeník, for which the permit for extraction has not yet been granted.
‘Socioeconomic study in the sector of final products made from minerals reveals that the number of jobs created in the sector minerals processing is 30-40 times higher than the number of jobs in the mineral sector’ (quoted on page 31 of the study entitled ‘Survey of minerals planning politics in Europe’ commissioned by DG Enterprise and Industry).
Latest Available (revised):The latest available updated version of the legislation incorporating changes made by subsequent legislation and applied by our editorial team. Changes we have not yet applied to the text, can be found in the ‘Changes to Legislation’ area.
Original (As adopted by EU): The original version of the legislation as it stood when it was first adopted in the EU. No changes have been applied to the text.
Access essential accompanying documents and information for this legislation item from this tab. Dependent on the legislation item being viewed this may include:
Use this menu to access essential accompanying documents and information for this legislation item. Dependent on the legislation item being viewed this may include:
Click 'View More' or select 'More Resources' tab for additional information including: