Search Legislation

Income Tax (Trading and Other Income) Act 2005

Chapter 7: Annual payments not otherwise charged
Overview

2605.The Chapter rewrites the part of section 18(3) Schedule D Case III (a) of ICTA which deals with annual payments and the parts of Schedule D Cases IV and V which deal with foreign annual payments.

2606.Under section 18(3) of ICTA there are no individual charges on income from different types of source within the Schedule D Case IV or V charge. The system of identifying and classifying income by Schedule and Case is replaced by individual charges on types of income, which previously would have fallen under a general Schedular/Case charge. In the context of income which would have previously been charged under Case IV or V, as appropriate, the charge is being fully integrated with the equivalent income arising from a UK source.

2607.This Chapter sets out the charge to income tax on any annual payments that are not charged to tax by any other provision of this Act or any other legislation. Annuity payments made under purchased life annuities and distributions from unauthorised unit trusts (which in the source legislation are treated as annual payments) are generally regarded as investment income. So the charge to tax for this income is in Part 4 of this Act. Royalties which are annual payments are generally regarded as income from intellectual property and are therefore taxed alongside other intellectual property income under Chapter 2 of Part 5 of this Act. Annual payments derived from telecommunication rights are also taxed under a separate Chapter, Chapter 4 of Part 5 of this Act. So, as the annual payments charge in Chapter 7 of Part 5 of this Act takes effect only if an amount is not otherwise charged to income tax, there is no overlap between the charge under this Chapter and the ex-Case III charges elsewhere in this Act.

2608.The charge to tax is in the penultimate Chapter of Part 5 of this Act to emphasise that it is a residual charge.

2609.The exemptions from the charge to income tax on annual payments are in Part 6 of this Act.

2610.The phrase “annual payment” is retained but not defined. The phrase is not defined in the source legislation. Instead it derives its meaning from an extensive body of case law. That case law illustrates that the phrase has a meaning for tax purposes far different from its natural one. Replacing that phrase risks breaking the link to case law without making the law any clearer or easier to understand. Because of the volume and complexity of the case law, defining “annual payment” comprehensively in this Act is impracticable and also risks changing the law.

2611.But it is possible to derive from the case law the main characteristics of an annual payment.

2612.For example, Jenkins L.J., in Commissioners of Inland Revenue v Whitworth Park Coal Company (1959), 38 TC 531 HL (at pages 548 to 550) regarded the following propositions as established:

(i)

To come within the Rule as an “other annual payment” the payment in question must be ejusdem generis with the specific instances given in the shape of interest of money and annuities (Hill v Gregory 6 TC 39; Earl Howe v Commissioners of Inland Revenue 7 TC 289)…;

(ii)

The payment in question must fall to be made under some binding legal obligation as distinct from a being a mere voluntary payment (Smith v Smith 1923)…;

(iii)

The fact that the obligation to pay is imposed by an Order of the Court and does not arise by virtue of a contract does not exclude the payment from Rule 1(a) of Case III (Smith v Smith 1923; CIR v Corporation of London (as Conservators of Epping Forest) 34 TC 293) …;

(iv)

The payment in question must possess the essential quality of recurrence implied by the description “annual” (Smith v Smith 1923) …;

(v)

The payment in question must be in the nature of a “pure income” profit in the hands of the recipient (Earl Howe v CIR 7 TC 289).

2613.The value of the first proposition is not without doubt. Not only has Parliament changed the genus from that considered in Hill v Gregory and Earl Howe, but the Court of Appeal in R - v - Special Commissioners of Income Tax ex parte Shaftesbury Homes and Arethusa Training Ship (1922), 8 TC 367 CA, in construing “any yearly interest or other annual payment” held that the expression “other annual payment” could not be construed eiusdem generis with the expression “any yearly interest”.

Section 683: Charge to tax on annual payments not otherwise charged

2614.This section is based on section 18(1) and (3) (Schedule D Case III (a) and Cases IV and V) of ICTA. Subsection (1) charges residual annual payments to tax.

2615.The charge to tax in the source legislation is in respect of “any annuity or other annual payment”. The reference to “any annuity or other” is omitted because most annuities are not charged to tax under Chapter 7 of Part 5 of this Act but under Part 4 of this Act or ITEPA. Including a reference to annuities might therefore be misleading.

2616.Likewise the examples of annual payments in Schedule D Case III (a) are omitted on the basis that including these risks misleading the reader either by excluding a right which may give rise to an annual payment or by including rights which may not.

2617.The words “whether such payment is payable within or out of the United Kingdom” in Schedule D Case III (a) are also omitted. See the commentary on section 369 of this Act.

2618.The charge to tax in the source legislation excludes “any payment chargeable under Schedule A”. It is not necessary to rewrite this as the priority rules (see section 575 (2)) ensure that property income is taxed under Part 3 of this Act and not under any other Part.

2619.Subsection (2) ensures that any exemption from other charges to income tax is not reversed by the charge under this Chapter. It protects an exemption, whether provided by Part 6 of this Act or other legislation.

2620.Subsection (3) rewrites “or whether the same is received and payable half-yearly or at any shorter or more distant periods”.

Section 684: Income charged

2621.This section sets out the amount charged to tax, which is the full amount of the annual payments (subsection (1)). It is based on sections 64 and 65(1) of ICTA.

2622.The words “without any deduction” in section 64 of ICTA are omitted. It is unnecessary to reproduce this phrase because one of the defining characteristics of an annual payment is that the recipient may make no deductions for expenses from it. See also the commentary on section 370 of this Act.

2623.Subsection (2) makes subsection (1) subject to the rules in Part 8 of this Act. Part 8 sets out the special rules which apply to foreign income including allowable deductions from foreign income and the remittance basis (see further the commentary on Part 8).

2624.Subsection (3) signposts the tax provision in ICTA which deals with the position of a person who receives income from a discretionary trust.

Section 685: Person liable

2625.This section states who is liable for any tax charged and is based on section 59(1) of ICTA. The phrase “receiving or entitled to” is retained because it is generally understood and has been widely interpreted by the courts. See further the commentary on section 371 of this Act.

Section 686: Payments received after deduction of tax

2626.Subsection (1) confirms that if income tax has been deducted by the payer of the annual payment, the recipient is treated as having paid that income tax. It is based on sections 348(1) and 349(1) of ICTA. The gap otherwise filled by case law (see Allchin v Corporation of South Shields (1943), 25 TC 445 HL, particularly Viscount Simon LC on page 461, Stokes v Bennett, (1953) 34 TC 337 HC, and Grosvenor Place Estates Ltd v Roberts (1960), 39 TC 433 CA) has been expressly rewritten. See further the commentary on section 426 of this Act.

Back to top

Options/Help

Print Options

Close

Explanatory Notes

Text created by the government department responsible for the subject matter of the Act to explain what the Act sets out to achieve and to make the Act accessible to readers who are not legally qualified. Explanatory Notes were introduced in 1999 and accompany all Public Acts except Appropriation, Consolidated Fund, Finance and Consolidation Acts.

Close

More Resources

Access essential accompanying documents and information for this legislation item from this tab. Dependent on the legislation item being viewed this may include:

  • the original print PDF of the as enacted version that was used for the print copy
  • lists of changes made by and/or affecting this legislation item
  • confers power and blanket amendment details
  • all formats of all associated documents
  • correction slips
  • links to related legislation and further information resources