Schedule 2: Procedural requirements applicable to NDA’s Strategy
478.Schedule 2 sets out various procedural arrangements for preparing and revising the NDA’s strategy, required under section 11.
479.As regards timing, paragraph 2 requires the NDA to prepare its first strategy within twelve months of section 11 coming into force and, under paragraph 3, thereafter to review its strategy at least every five years. Paragraph 3(5), however, leaves it open to the NDA to revise its strategy at any time and, in the NDA’s early years at least, the expectation is that it will amend and adjust it on a more frequent basis.
480.The initial strategy, and any subsequent revision of it which significantly alters the NDA’s priorities as between different installations or sites, changes its objectives for an installation or site or significantly increases the cost of giving effect to its strategy, are subject to approval by the Secretary of State (paragraph 5). As a minimum, the strategy must also be submitted for re-approval every five years (paragraph 3). This reflects the fact that, whilst the NDA is intended to have substantial management freedom and to operate at arms length from Government, Ministers must exercise strategic control over its activities and be accountable for its actions. Approval of the strategy and the annual work plan (section 13) is the means by which this strategic control is to be exercised.
481.Paragraph 4 of the Schedule expressly requires the NDA, in preparing, revising or reviewing its strategy to consult the nuclear regulators; relevant local authorities; those persons with control of installations or sites for which the NDA is responsible, their employees and their Trade Union representatives; and any bodies such as site liaison committees which have been, or may be, established for the purpose of consulting local stakeholders about activities carried on at, or in connection with, a relevant installation or site. Whilst each of these must be consulted, there is no constraint on the NDA consulting other stakeholder groups or the public at large. Equally, the Schedule does not prescribe the basis on which consultation should take place – the Government’s view is that it should be left open to the NDA and stakeholder groups to develop and, as necessary subsequently change arrangements which best serve their purposes. The NDA is required to have regard to all representations made to it (paragraph 4(3)). Paragraph 4(5) provides that consultation can take place in relation to a designated installation, site or facility that has been designated by a direction which has not yet come into force (see the notes for section 5(1) for more on the timing of designation directions). This takes account of the fact that when it is first established the NDA will need to start work on preparing its annual plan in readiness for its first year of operation, expected to be 1 April 2005. The designations will come into force on that date.
482.Paragraph 5(2) of the Schedule, read in conjunction with section 12(2)(f), requires the NDA, when submitting its strategy for approval or re-approval, to provide a report on the representations made to it by stakeholders and to explain the reasons for the recommendations contained in the strategy. Paragraph 5(3) requires the Secretary of State to consult the Scottish Ministers before approving anything relating to responsibilities in section 6(3). In addition, paragraph 5(4) requires that before approving the strategy, the Secretary of State must consult Scottish Ministers on any proposals for sites in England and Wales relating to the non-processing treatment, storage or disposal of hazardous material that would have an effect on the management of hazardous material in Scotland, or the availability of a site in England and Wales for the treatment, storage or disposal of hazardous material located in Scotland. Paragraphs 5(6) to 5(8) deal with the situation where, for whatever reason, the Secretary of State decides not to approve the strategy as recommended and, in particular, give him the power to make directions requiring the NDA to modify the strategy in respect of any of the matters specified in paragraph 5(7). The rationale for this is that those matters are so important that they must be subject to strategic control by Ministers and that, in the event of a fundamental disagreement, their views should prevail. However, as paragraph 5(10) makes clear, in respect of other matters there will still be an onus on the NDA to produce a strategy that Ministers will approve. The NDA and the regulators must be consulted before any direction is given (paragraph 5(9)).
483.Paragraph 6 of the Schedule requires the NDA to publish its strategy, as approved, in the manner which, in its opinion, is most appropriate for bringing it to the attention of stakeholders and, on the same basis, to publish a report on the representations made to it by stakeholders on what the strategy should contain. In both cases, however, publication is subject to exclusion of anything which the Secretary of State considers to be against the interests of national security or which the NDA considers would seriously and prejudicially affect the interest of an individual or particular body of persons. In determining whether to exclude any information from publication the NDA must have regard to whether the harm caused by publication is likely to outweigh the benefits.
